Paula
Jolin’s In the Name of God is a
powerful book. I like how she wrote the story from the perspective of a devout
Muslim. It is no secret that in this day and age, it is difficult to be Muslim.
There are a lot of prejudices against that religion, and I appreciate her bravery
to tell the other side of the battle against the United States. Obviously
Muslims are as passionate about their beliefs as Americans, otherwise there
would not be this war. It was very interesting to read how Nadia progressed
from simply being devout in her religion, to being an extremist. I feel like
that is how most extremists are created, by charismatic people taking advantage
of naïve people. Jolin’s novel is a great way to show young readers the danger
of getting caught up in your own opinion, without allowing yourself to see
other points of view, to be willing to understand others. Nadia ends up pushing
her family away, and almost commits the worst mortal sin. Thankfully, her
brother’s appearance at the hotel shocks Nadia enough to make her open her
eyes, and realize the horror of her situation.
I
think this book could be a difficult sell to my young readers. While the
message is good, it is not the most exciting story. The story is full of
uncertainty, angst, confusion, and anger, which all of my seventh graders experience,
but the plot is slow. There are a few scenes, like when Fowzi gets taken, that are
suspenseful and intriguing, but for the most part, this is a story about Nadia’s
battle with herself. The ending, while very happy, seems so unfinished. Nadia
is being led out of a hotel with a bomb strapped to her body, wouldn’t her
brother feel that? And what exactly did she do with the bomb? Considering that I
felt jilted at the end, I know my seventh graders would throw a fit.
No comments:
Post a Comment